Problem No. 23.
Original for the Pittsburgh Post by A. Ellermann, Buenos Aires, Argentine Republic
Black 13 Pieces
White 9 Pieces
This problem is the one I composed in Montevideo at a dinner given upon the occasion of the distribution of prizes to winners of a chess tournament held there. I was asked to show methods of constructing a chess problem, and notwithstanding the merry surroundings I composed this problem in 15 minutes, and you can see the result is good with excellent originality. So wonderful was my chess mood on this occasion that I solved all the problems of the Good Companion Folder in a half hour.
Arnaldo Ellerman, Buenos Aires.
- March 19, 1922, Page 60, Pittsburgh Daily Post
Clip
Solution to No. 23 By Arnaldo Ellerman, Buenos Aires.
Key 1-Q-B8.
Criticism.
An easy sort of waiting move
-F. H. of Parnassus.
The claim of 1-Q-QKt7 for key is defeated by Kt-KB2. Claim of 1-Kt-QB5 ck is impossible as it discovers check from the black rook. To have composed this problem in the small space of time as indicated by the author is, in my opinion, very noteworthy. I am inclined to the belief, however, that the germ had been previously implanted in the chess cell of the author's brain, otherwise his chess mood was not only wonderful on this occasion, but rather abnormally brilliant.
-George A.A. Hollander.
This problem is rather easy to solve, although almost perfect in construction
- Harry J. Willinsky.
Too many plugs with the black pawns at KR6 and QB4.
- Odin A. Herr, 6137 Carpenter Street, Philadelphia, Pa.
A fairly good problem, but not filled to the brim with such wonderful XLNT originality as the composer's letter would indicate.
- Dr. J.H. Tarnedde, McKees Rocks, Pa.
Too many black pawns, but this is excusable considering the speed with which it was composed. The four mates are interesting and somewhat hard to find.
- Sidney Neu, Edgewood Park, Pa.
April 09, 1922, Page 38, Pittsburgh Daily Post
Clip







